Reserve Bank Governor Anna Breman

The Reserve Bank yesterday did exactly what the Government must have hoped it would not do.

It put a spanner in their re-election chances.

Not only did it raise interest rates yesterday, but there quickly emerged from within the banking sector the view that it was now on track to raise rates again in October, just before the election.

And now that the Bank is attributing views by name to members of the Monetary Policy Committee, it is possible to conclude that the Governor, Anna Breman, was less enthusiastic about the hawkish move yesterday than some of the external members of the Committee.

Nevertheless, the record of the meeting says the decision to raise rates was determined by consensus.

But the impact of the move was probably captured by a cartoon published shortly after the rate had been announced by KiwiBank.

It shows a perspiring Kiwi trying to reach the top of a hill named “Economic Growth” but having to drag a ball and chain behind with “Interest Rates” written on the ball.

Labour were quick to climb into the Government over the rate rise.

“Christopher Luxon and Nicola Willis were quick to take credit when mortgage rates came down,” said the party’s Finance Spokesperson Barbara Edmonds.

“They need to take responsibility now that they’re set to go back up.

Advertisment

“National’s flawed plan was to let the Reserve Bank do the heavy lifting, but this just shows they have no plan.

“The independent Reserve Bank has been doing what it can to help with high costs.

“Ultimately, what New Zealand needs is a Government that is focused on helping people with the high cost of living and making our economy more productive.

“Instead, Christopher Luxon is making things worse.

“National has been crowing about bringing mortgage rates down, so they need to explain to Kiwis why mortgages are going up.”

Finance Minister Nicola Willis however saw the Bank’s argument that growth was returning to the economy – hence the need to control inflation — as a plus.

“The Reserve Bank is essentially saying such is their confidence in a strengthening economy that they think they now need to be very careful to watch that inflation doesn’t stay out of control,” she told RNZ.

Willis said having inflation under control was needed to keep “sustainably high employment”, blaming current high unemployment rates on the rampant inflation that followed the Covid pandemic.

The Bank’s Governor Anna Breman, in her statement announcing the rise in the Official Cash Rate by 25 basis points to 2.5 per cent, said that with inflation still above target and economic activity expected to strengthen, some further reduction in monetary stimulus was likely to be required to return inflation to the 2 percent target midpoint.

“Future OCR decisions will depend on how incoming data, price-setting behaviour, and the strength of economic activity affect medium-term inflation pressures,” her statement said.

But though the Bank’s Monetary Policy Committee stressed that the decision was the consensus of the Committee, the record of the meeting suggests there was a division with the Bank members and one external member on one side and two external members on the other. 

“The Committee judged that there are both risks to the upside and the downside. In the discussion, Prasanna Gai and Hayley Gourley assessed that risks were skewed to the upside, while Anna Breman, Paul Conway, Carl Hansen and Karen Silk viewed risks as broadly balanced,” the record of the meeting said.

Gai, Gourley and Hansen are external directors.

“Prasanna Gai noted that, despite the recent decline in energy prices, some indirect effects from earlier increases in energy-related input costs may also still flow through to consumer prices. Karen Silk added that the recent depreciation of the exchange rate could, if sustained, increase imported inflation,” the record said.

“Carl Hansen commented that non-tradables inflation remains elevated and that administered price inflation could remain persistently high.

“Paul Conway observed that firms’ price-setting behaviour could also prove more sensitive to further cost increases, particularly after an extended period of elevated inflation.

“Some businesses may also seek to rebuild margins as demand recovers.

“Prasanna Gai also highlighted the risk that the Middle East shock could coordinate price-setting behaviour, licensing firms to pass on costs more readily than otherwise.

“Anna Breman noted that if demand remains weak, firms may have less ability to pass higher costs on to consumers and intelligence from recent business engagements points to divergence in ability to pass on cost increases.”

There was thus a clear division between Gai (the Professor of Macroeconomics at the University of Auckland) and Breman over the ability of firms to raise prices.

Reserve Bank Monetary Policy Committee members, Hanna Gourley and Prasanna Gai

Westpac Kelly Eckhold saw the Committee as being divided.

“The balance of the MPC appears unchanged: the hawks remain Gai, Gourley and Hansen while the more dovish group includes Breman, Silk and Conway,” he said.

“Gai and Gourley see upside risks to the inflation outlook while the rest see the inflation risks as better balanced.”

It is interesting to speculate what might have happened in the years before the Monetary Policy Committee was established by then Finance Minister Grant Robertson in 2019; would Breman on her own not have raised the OCR?

However, the division was obviously resolved, and Breman agreed to the raise.

As Governor, she has to have greater political sensitivities than economics professors, and she seemed to acknowledge that in her media conference yesterday afternoon.

“If you look at New Zealand’s growth right now, it’s really driven by the exporting sectors,” she said.

Agriculture, tourism, and manufacturing have been doing quite well, and remarkably well even with the uncertainty around the world.

“But the domestic sectors, the retailers, the small businesses, hospitality, some of those have been performing less well.

“And that’s been because demand from regular households has been weak when inflation has been high.

“Bringing inflation back down will help see stronger domestic demand and also see then that employment will come back.

“So it’s not an easy thing, but it is important because in the long run, it will make growth come back and also give us a stronger labor market.”

However, the Prime Minister and the Finance Minister are not interested in the long run for the rest of the year.

Teetering in the polls with the cost of living the biggest issue,  they would undoubtedly have preferred that there be no rise in the Official Cash Rate till September at the earliest, when it would have little time to make itself felt before the election on November 7.

Kiwibank Chief Economist Jarrod Kerr and economist Alexandra Turcu said the Reserve Bank decision emphasised risks to medium-term inflation, especially from second-round effects and price-setting behaviour.

“We disagree that the risks are to the upside,” they said.

“The medium-term outlook for inflation is already tame, with a weak labour market and uneven recovery.”

If Kiwibank are right, and there is no real recovery between now and the election, then you would have to conclude life just got more difficult for National, which surely needs some bright economic news in Auckland and Wellington if it is going to remain in power.

Image courtesy of POLITIK