
The Government is going back on moves it made less than a year ago to distance Ministers from fast-track planning approvals.
Using the pretext of bringing competition to the grocery sector, it is now proposing to give Ministers an ultimate say on fast-track applications.
The proposal has been introduced into Parliament without any cost-benefit analysis or any overview from the new Ministry of Regulation.
Even Sir Robert Muldoon’s National Development Act did not provide for as much political control as that proposed in the Fast Track Approvals Amendment Bill, which has been introduced by Infrastructure Minister Chris Bishop.
The proposal has been the subject of a damning condemnation by the Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment, Simon Upton.
In a submission to the Environment Committee last week, he said the Amendment Bill would:
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Make the approval of applications almost inevitable.
- Exert further ministerial control by enabling the Minister to direct the Environmental Protection Authority on the performance of its functions and duties, and the exercise of its powers.
- Further speed up a process to the point that proper scrutiny could not be reliably undertaken.
- Limit any public or community input.
-
-
-
-
-
-
Upton was a National backbench MP in the dying days of the Muldoon National Government between 1981 and 1984, and he was a staunch supporter of a small group of MPs who looked to Derek Quigley and Ruth Richardson to oppose Muldoon’s megalomania.
They particularly opposed Sir Robert Muldoon’s use in 1982 of the 1948 Economic Stabilisation Act to implement extensive, direct government control over the New Zealand economy, most notably a comprehensive, nationwide wage and price freeze.
Muldoon also used the Act to fix interest rates, extending the Government’s control over the financial sector without specific parliamentary approval.
Labour’s then Deputy Leader, the constitutional lawyer, Sir Geoffrey Palmer, argued this was an example of Muldoon’s “unbridled power” and amounted to a dictatorship of the Executive.
In 1987, the Lange Labour Government repealed the Act.
But Upton told the Environment Committee that what Bishop was proposing took us back to the days when the Act was in force.
“The Government could, by regulation, intervene in every corner of economic life without public scrutiny,” he said.
“Any intervention believed by a government to contribute to economic stability could, by fiat, be imposed.
“In a different, but analogous way, this Bill would allow the Executive to impose its view of regional or national benefits, regardless of the views of the public (who are often the ultimate owners of the resources at stake) and regardless of standard cost-benefit analysis.
“It takes us back to a world in which Ministers decree what is or isn’t good for communities.”
He said it represented a significant expansion in Executive power when it came to dealing with public resources and environmental impacts.
There would be no guard rails and nothing to stop a Minister proposing mining on the Coromandel or Great Barrier, arguing that it was a significant regional benefit.
The Environmental Protection Authority panels would then be obliged to put that demand above any other considerations when considering a fast-track application.
“If anyone should be defining ‘regional or national benefits’ for panels, it should be Parliament, not the Executive,” he said.
Bishop’s decision to include the draconian Ministerial powers looks like an attempt to relitigate changes that the same Select Committee forced him to make over the substantial legislation.
The Fast Track Approvals Act allows the Minister to consider regional or national benefits when a decision is being made as to whether an application should be made to the independent Environmental Protection Authority Panel.
But the Select Committee was at pains to remove the Minister from the Committee decision-making process.
Originally, the Government proposed that Ministers would have a right of veto over any decision made by the panel.
“Many submitters opposed this proposal, saying that Ministers could be susceptible to bias, corruption, or potential lobbying,” the Committee’s report said.
“We agree that it would be more appropriate for an expert panel to be the final substantive decision-maker on all approvals, rather than the joint Ministers.
“We consider that this amendment would give greater confidence that decision-making is independent, objective, and well-informed.”
But Bishop has now found a workaround.
Instead of the Minister having a right of veto — and the ability to send a decision back if he didn’t like it — he will now have the power to direct the panel in a particular direction.
The proposal has its origins in the Government’s hopes of increasing competition in the supermarket sector.
The pro-business New Zealand Initiative, which has both the main supermarket chains as members, has continually argued that one of the reasons for the lack of competition is the difficulty new entrants have getting resource consent for new supermarkets.
Thus, the Ministerial powers that Bishop is seeking would allow him to specifically require a consenting panel to take supermarket competition into account.
Ironically, the Initiative has some reservations about this.
They are concerned that a Ministerial statement could be too vague and could place new evidentiary burdens on applicants.
“By demanding proof of ‘long-term regional or national benefits’, it encourages panels to apply subjective judgements about scale and time horizon, which in turn may exclude exactly the sort of incremental, commercially led projects that create footholds for new competitors and stimulate economic activity,” their submission said.
The Initiative argued, however, that the benefits of the Ministerial directive would depend entirely on how the power was exercised.
Without statutory obligations for consultation and publication, a directive could become a mechanism for opaque ministerial direction, they argued.
They suggested that all directives be subject to public consultation, be published in the Gazette and on the EPA website, and include a statement of the evidential and analytical standards expected of applicants and panels.
That, however, would not answer Upton’s point.
“This version(The Amendment Bill) has no guardrails, it’s got no protections, stuff can just come from heaven, bing and apply, even to stuff which is already in the process,” he said.
“My view of fast track as it now exists is it’s not perfect, and it’s putting a lot of pressure on people, and it’s early days. We can’t yet say it’s an unmitigated success.
“It is pretty transparent, and panels are demonstrating that they are actually interested in taking information from people other than the narrow list.
“What this is trying to do is to take away all of the sort of buffer and flexibility that is in the existing legislation.
“I don’t think you can fix this. The best thing is to drop this and have some confidence in what you actually enacted.”
That would be a brave call for a Select Committee chaired by a first-term backbencher (Catherine Wedde) to go back and tell Bishop that he should withdraw his Bill.
But there are already concerns within the National caucus about what some see as his Muldoonist tendencies, which have been demonstrated with his demands that Auckland intensify its housing in the middle-class suburbs that ACT leader David Seymour calls “villa-ville”.
Upton is still a highly regarded figure within National circles, and his opposition to this Bill will be important.
Bishop will need to find a compromise.








