The report of the Finance and Expenditure Select Committee will not be the silver bullet that immediately produces a more competitive banking sector, as the Prime Minister appeared to promise back in March.
Once again, it seems the spin was mightier than the reality.
The Committee has run with the weight of much of the evidence that it was given and focused on the Reserve Bank as the source of the way the trading banks go about their highly profitable businesses.
We will hear more about this today when the Reserve Bank launches its 2025 review of key capital settings.
Back in March, at his investment summit, the Prime Minister said our banking sector was also “in for a shakeup.”
“We want more competition and have put the major four Australian banks in New Zealand on notice,” he said.
The report from the Select Committee does not go much further than the Commerce Commission’s Inquiry last year into personal banking services.
Clearly, the Committee had difficulty coming to a consensus, and there are minority opinions from both Labour and the Greens.
The Inquiry was a joint effort by the Finance and Expenditure Committee and the Primary Production Committee and employed as an advisor, the former Productivity Commission chair, Murray Sherwin.’
His role at the Reserve Bank during the Rogernomics years seems to have been enough to cause the Ardern Government to replace him with the left-wing economist Ganesh Nana.
Last year, the National-led Government, rather than replace Nana, abolished the Commission.
This has left the Government without an economic think tank focused on issues like competition and productivity in the economy.
So the Select Committee has attempted to fill the gap.
Its recommendations broadly follow two paths.
It has looked at the role the Reserve Bank’s setting of capital assets play (or don’t play) in the setting of interest rates, and it has focused more broadly on the Bank’s role as a prudential regulator of the banking system.
The capital assets issue was singled out by Federated Farmers in its submission to the Committee as the main issue.
Because the Reserve Bank requires the banks to hold sufficient reserve assets to cope with a one-in-two-hundred-year financial crisis, and it also requires, as part of that, that they hold a higher percentage of each farm loan in reserve assets than is required for urban housing loans.
So farm mortgage rates are higher.
“That simply doesn’t make sense,” said Waikato Federated Farmers’ Chair of Economics and Finance, Garry Reymer, when he appeared before the Committee.
“Pastoral farming has been, and historically has been, one of the best and safest, most profitable sectors of the New Zealand economy.”
Three Bank CEOs who appeared before the Committee agreed that the risk weighting policies were conservative.
ASB chair Dame Therese Walsh said her Bank believed the Reserve Bank was correct when it adjusted the reserve asset ratios in 2019.
“We did need to increase the capital settings in New Zealand,” she said.
“So we were supportive.
“Probably where we differ is that possibly it doesn’t need to go as far as it is going.”
The Bank’s CEO, Vittoria Shortt, said the Bank had submitted in 2019 to the Reserve Bank that the reserve asset levels should be lower than the Bank was proposing.
National Rangitikei MP, Suze Redmayne, asked ANZ CEO Antonia Watson what she would do to lower lending rates to farmers if she had a magic wand.
“If I had a magic wand, I would ask the government, you, regulators, just take a step back, look at our risk weighting on an internationally comparable basis,” she said.
“At the moment, we have a lot of conservatism in our risk-weighted assets.”
Watson said New Zealand should compare its asset ratios with those of other countries around the world.
“I think you would acknowledge that New Zealand is a more risky country. I think there’s absolutely reason for New Zealand banks to hold more capital for all the reasons we’ve talked about, tourism, export-led economy, driven by product prices, subject to natural disasters, all those kinds of things.
“So, I think New Zealand is more risky, but once we’ve got those facts, we sit down as a country and say, where on that risk spectrum do we want to be?
“How much prudential risk do we want for the banks compared to allowing more competition, those sorts of things.
“And I think that’s a conversation for New Zealand, not a conversation for me as a banker.”
Perhaps not surprisingly, the Bank, in its submission to the Committee, was more cautious about the impact the asset ratios were having on interest rates.
“The Reserve Bank noted that capital requirements are only one part of the variation in interest rates borrowers face,” the Committee’s report said.
“For example, on average, farm lending interest rates in June 2024 were around 1.7 per cent higher than residential mortgage interest rates, but only around 0.6 per cent of this can be explained by the difference in regulatory capital requirements for these two categories.
“Variation in lending rates is also influenced by operating costs, provisioning for risk, and other factors.”
The report says the “Big Four” banks are accredited to use internal models to calculate their own risk-weighted capital requirements.
Risk weights represent the likelihood of a certain loan type defaulting. The higher the risk weight, the more likely that loan type is to create unexpected losses, and so the higher the capital a bank must hold in reserve.
That is the basis for the higher asset requirements for rural loans and their higher interest rates.
So the Committee has recommended that the Reserve Bank stop its immediate plans to increase the risk weights, and today it will unveil its plans to review the existing requirements.
Federated Farmers is hailing this as a major victory
“Politicians have clearly listened, recognising that farmers have been facing an unfair playing field for too long – and now they’ve presented concrete changes to start fixing it,” said the Feds’ banking spokesperson Mark Hooper.”
“This report backs what we’ve been saying for a long time – that these capital rules are stripping hundreds of millions of dollars out of rural New Zealand each year,” Hooper says.
“Overly conservative capital holding rules have only added additional and unnecessary costs onto farmers. They’ve also made it much harder for farmers to access capital to grow their businesses.”
But on banking competition more generally, the Committee’s report doesn’t go much further than the Commerce Commission.
It endorses the capital raise for KiwiBank, though Labour in a dissenting view opposes any private capital at all being used to strengthen the Bank.
That might seem ironic coming from a party which, when in Government, endorsed the use of private capital to sustain Air New Zealand.
The Committee supports the liberalisation of the ability for a financial institution to call itself a bank, but perhaps most interestingly wants the “Big Four” to regularly appear before the Committee every six months to answer a variety of questions, including revealing their profitability on transaction accounts (like a cheque account) which do not pay interest.
The banks will also have to front up every six months to the Primary Production Committee to discuss rural lending.
That may be the most important outcome from the Committee.
But how much the Banks will be prepared to reveal is another matter.
They were not entirely forthcoming with the Committee.
The report says that “for commercial sensitivity reasons”, they would not provide breakdowns of return on equity for different loan types.
One potentially powerful finding from the Committee was its overall conclusion that the regulatory requirements for Banks were unnecessarily convoluted and complex.
But any real change there would be bound to involve amendments to the Reserve Bank Act.
The Committee has not delivered the kind of king hit that the Prime Minister seemed to imply might be coming when he spoke to his Investment Summit in March.
Instead, it has added weight to the need for internal reforms at the Reserve Bank and possibly some legislative reforms down the track to the Bank’s empowering legislation.
And there are some other things it did not do.
During the hearings, ACT MP Mark Cameron had accused the Banks of “greenwashing” and was heavily critical of their role in the Net Zero Banking Alliance, a UN-sponsored move to get banks to include climate change as a consideration when making loans.
And NZ First MP Andy Foster has a private members’ bill which would stop banks from withdrawing banking services from customers whose political views or outlook may not align with the sensibilities of that institution.
The Committee has not gone as far as Cameron or Foster might have liked with a section that would seem subtly critical of their claims.
“While our members hold different views on the nature and importance of these kinds of products, we agree that greater transparency about climate-related disclosures and green lending products is needed,” the report said.
“Borrowers should be able to understand the costs associated with climate-related risks and opportunities.
“Visibility of the specific risk factors could encourage borrowers to make changes to their practices that mitigate these risks, and in turn reduce their cost of borrowing.
“Greater visibility also allows borrowers to compare loan offerings from lenders and make their choice of lender accordingly.
“Some of us would like to see the alternatives and comparisons to other products made clear. We agree that transparency of any risk assessment is important so that farmers and agri-business know what they can change about their practices to secure different lending rates.
“We recommend that the Reserve Bank require banks to provide greater clarity around interest rates connected to any natural hazards, climate-related disclosures, and green lending products.
“Some of us have the view that there was insufficient evidence presented that these requirements increased interest rates; in fact, the evidence was that these disclosures brought down lending costs for loan holders in some instances.”
What the Committee’s report surely shows is that the day-to-day complexity of banking does not easily lend itself to bumper stickers.
.









