Speaker Gerry Brownlee greets China's Chairman of the Standing Committee of the National People's Congress, Zhao Leji in Parliament last week.

When the number three politician in China’s hierarchy, the chairman of the Standing Committee of the National Peoples’ Congress, Zhao Leji, was in Wellington last week, it would have seemed like nothing had changed.

The welcome speech from Speaker Gerry Brownlee testified to the strength of the Sino-New Zealand relationship, which was long regarded in Beijing and in the West as one of the closest China had with a developed Western country.

That relationship was an essential pillar of New Zealand’s independent foreign policy, which saw it elected to the Security Council in 2015 and opened diplomatic doors around the world.

But what was taking place in Parliament’s Legislative Council Chamber was not the reality.

New Zealand’s attitude to China has changed.

That change has been led by two Ministers, Judith Collins and Winston Peters, and encouraged by the security services, Australia and some hawkish officials in the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade.

It has also been prompted by the current Government’s policy towards the United States, which is to make itself a “small target”.

That discourages public criticism from Ministers of the Trump administration.

The talks between New Zealand’s delegation led by Speaker Gerry Brownlee and the Chinese delegation led by Zhao Leji

But one of the key forces in the change has been the security agencies.

In the Clark and Key governments, New Zealand confined its criticism of China’s security activities against New Zealand to closed-door meetings with Chinese Ministers and officials.

Advertisment

That didn’t mean the security agencies turned a blind eye to Chinese activities.

It was often the practice to sweep Wellington offices for bugs if they had been visited by a large Chinese delegation.

But the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade has never publicly confirmed what POLITIK has been told were a number of bugs that were discovered installed in the new New Zealand Embassy in Beijing during its construction during the Key Government.

The agencies now routinely call China out and name it in statements alleging foreign interference in New Zealand politics.

Those statements have singled out the Chinese community in New Zealand as potential targets for Chinese political interference.

SIS Director General, Andrew Hampton, defined “foreign interference” in a recent speech to Dunstan High School.

“Foreign interference is essentially when a foreign state, through corruptive, coercive or deceptive means, tries to influence our people, institutions or government systems,” he said.

“Unfortunately, it’s our migrant and ethnic communities that are among those most at risk of foreign interference.

“There are foreign states that specifically target people with connections back to their own countries if they think they are speaking or acting out of turn.”

 There are no prizes for guessing which foreign state he might be talking about.

What is clear is that the SIS has stepped up its activities within the Chinese-New Zealand community.

POLITIK understands that its recent interrogation of two New Zealand Chinese businesspeople returning from a business trip to China has caused concern within the Chinese community.

Chiinese Ambassador Wang Xialong greets Speaker Gerry Brownlee at the Zhao Leji welcome

The relationship with China is also coloured by what appears to be Peters’ personal antagonism towards the Chinese Ambassador in Wellington, Wang Xialong.

That was evident when Wang last month wrote to a number of MPs who had attended a Taiwan National Day reception, saying they had violated New Zealand’s “one-China” policy.

Peters responded by saying he would describe to Wang the “essence of democracy” when he had a chance.

“He’s got a very, very thin understanding of it, and I’ll make sure he gets a better understanding of it,” Peters said.

The MPs who attended the event were all backbench MPs and therefore not part of the Government.

It is a distinction that seems lost on the Chinese.

Brownlee emphasised to Zhao during the formal welcome that he was there not as a representative of the Government but that he was speaking on behalf of all MPs in Parliament.

New Zealand’s constitutional subtleties also colour the ongoing confrontation with the Cook Islands over their decision to sign a series of agreements with China, some of which had security implications.

Government officials complain that China does not seem to understand that Cook Islanders are New Zealand citizens and that, therefore, the country cannot have its own unilateral foreign policy.

Peters, apparently, devoted more than half his meeting with Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi in Beijing earlier this year to trying to make this point.

New Zealand officials see the Cook Islands agreements and increased Chinese involvement across the Pacific as part of an attempt by China to upset the security balance in the region.

Last week, President Xi hosted Tongan King Tupou and emphasised the partnership between the two states.

 “No matter how the international situation changes, China has always been a trustworthy and good partner of Tonga and has always supported Tonga in safeguarding its national independence and sovereignty,” Xi said.

China’s inroads into the Pacific understandably worry Washington and Canberra and seem to have subtly changed attitudes within New Zealand’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade.

Speaker Gerry Brownlee with New Zealand’s Ambassador to China, Jonathan Austin, at the welcome for Zhao Leji.

New Zealand’s current Ambassador to China, Jonathan Austin, is the first this century to not speak Mandarin.

But he has a high-powered CV with stints as head of mission in Jakarta and Singapore, and also a term as the director of intelligence and assessment in the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet.

His appointment would seem to indicate a desire to take a more measured view of the China relationship.

He may have subtly indicated that when, instead of joining former Prime Minister Helen Clark and John Key at Beijing’s big September 3 parade to mark the end of its war with Japan, he was on an official visit to Mongolia, China’s pro-western northern neighbour.

All of this adds up to a distancing from the China we knew under Clark and Key, and to a certain extent, Ardern, and a return to the old Anglo allies, the United States and Australia.

China’s response so far seems to have been to take a long view; to understand that New Zealand business leaders hold a less suspicious attitude to China than the Government.

That was evident last year in a meeting with Chinese Premier, Li Qiang, some of the country’s most successful businesspeople, like Fonterra CEO, Mike Hurell and Les Mills CEO, Philip Mills, made the same point.

Their relationship with China went beyond basic economics and extended into deep and important personal relationships.

The ultimate argument, of course, is that China accounts for the same value of our exports as our next two biggest customers, the USA and Australia combined.

Maybe that is why Brownlee was conciliatory at the Parliamentary reception for Zhao.

“You do us a great honour in being here, and I look forward to the discussions that we will have shortly,” he said.

“We recognise that our country has a population about one two hundredth the size of China.

“So the willingness that you have to embrace discussions with us, trade with us, and have relations with us is very welcome by us. “

Zhao offered a similarly conciliatory response, which may have also underlined the core factors that have driven the relationship in the past.

“The Maori proverb puts it very well with your food basket and my food basket, the people will thrive,” he said.

“We should see each other as opportunities and partners, strengthen dialogue, exchange and cooperation, and work for continued, fresh progress in our comprehensive strategic partnership.”

But what would Winston and Judith say to that?

Image courtesy of POLITIK