Labour’s Housing spokesman Phil Twyford yesterday sent POLITIK 10 bullet points of his criticisms of the new Social Housing legislation. Because the points were technical we referred them to the Minister’s office for clarification.

The Minister, through a spokesman, has done that and so we present the debate — Twyford v Bennett.

PHIL TWYFORD 

PAULA BENNETT 

“The Bill gives the Minister the ability to gazette Housing New Zealand land so that if it is sold Housing New Zealand doesn’t get any money and it all goes to the Crown directly.”Incorrect. There is a small portion of social housing land that is not owned by Housing New Zealand, but is owned by the Crown. This clause makes it clear that where the Crown manages and sells this land without any involvement from Housing New Zealand, the money will be paid to the Crown directly.
This Bill gives Bill English complete carte blanche to sell state housesThe power in proposed s 50E is provided to both Hons Bennett and English, acting jointly. It’s not a “carte-blanche” power, in that the power can only be exercised for any one or more of the social housing reform objectives.    The objective  can be found here: 
This contract can be on “any terms and conditions (including as to consideration)” the Minister wishes Correct. Of course, the contracts will be negotiated with the buyers. 
He can also direct Housing New Zealand to take any action to facilitate the sales process Broadly correct, except that there’s no “direction” – rather, the Minister just does it as if they were Housing New Zealand. 
The Bill will exempt him from all relevant enactments including the objectives and functions of HNZ (social responsibility, environmental responsibility, and good financial oversight Correct, although it’s not just English – it’s English and Bennett and the rule of law as to the validity of these powers – There’s no exemption from the rule of law (in the Dicey/constitutional sense). Rather, the Minister isn’t constrained by “any rule of law relating to capacity or validity of acts”. 
It exempts the transactions from parts of the Public Works Act transfer provisions (including right of first refusal) Correct, although these PWA provisions would not have applied in any case.  The point is there are no Public Works Act obligations in respect of the Housing New Zealand properties to be sold.  
The Bill provides that he can delegate these powers to the chief executive of the Ministry as well meaning that officials can exercise these powers and this section is again exempted from the rule of law The bill allows for the statutory powers to be delegated to officials.  This is the default position for all statutory powers.  However, there is no exemption from the rule of law.* 
 Exempted from legal challenge except judicial review Housing NZ will bear liability in respect of the contracts it is bound to  and not the Minister. So, if Housing NZ has an obligation under a  transfer contract with a buyer of social houses (i.e. to hand over the keys by a particular date), and fails to meet that obligation, Housing NZ will be liable – the Minister will not be liable. Section 50R(6) is clear that judicial review is still available – as in, if a member of the public felt that the Minister has exercised the power unlawfully (because it’s not for a SHRP objective, for instance), they can ask the courts to review that decision.  
All officials are made immune from legal liability for the actions of the Minister Incorrect. Board members and employees of Housing New Zealand and its subsidiaries are not liable for decisions made by the Minister. Otherwise, the usual Crown Entities Act liability/immunity arrangements apply.  
Exempts HNZ from the right of first refusal proposals under the Public Works Act  The Public Works Act offer-back requirements do not, and have never applied in respect of the properties to be sold.  Rights of first refusal under Treaty settlement legislation will not be affected by this provision.   
The “rule of law” is the fundamental constitutional provision that means all persons, including the Crown and lawmakers themselves, are subject to law. In a parliamentary democracy like ours, Parliament makes law.  So the view that Parliament’s legislation can exempt someone from the “rule of law” is oxymoronic. Of course, Parliament can legislation exemptions from particular rules of law, but not from the rule of law.

Sorry, but access to POLITIK requires a subscription. Subs start at $15.95 per month. (All prices include GST, full details including Ts&Cs on the FAQs page) Subscriptions include the highly regarded daily newsletter, POLITIKToday. (Don't worry, you can cancel at any time.)

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Nulla ac tellus sed purus sollicitudin pharetra. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Vestibulum nec dolor vel ante egestas fermentum. Sed consectetur libero at mauris commodo efficitur. Nunc malesuada auctor dui in viverra. Suspendisse faucibus lacinia neque, in eleifend sapien dignissim eget. Vivamus ipsum augue, aliquet iaculis aliquam in, ullamcorper ut risus. Aliquam ut elit magna. Nunc id odio libero. Ut egestas magna et ex fringilla tristique. In volutpat elementum nisl. Vestibulum a risus efficitur, fermentum mauris in, malesuada enim.

Quisque ut rhoncus risus. Sed aliquam dui et urna efficitur, a efficitur mi interdum. Suspendisse vitae tortor neque. Duis sed accumsan enim. Morbi sed tincidunt metus. Donec id sollicitudin quam. Pellentesque imperdiet non turpis feugiat vestibulum. Nunc maximus ligula non tortor sagittis, nec malesuada ligula dignissim. Sed consectetur mi mauris. Donec ac ullamcorper lacus. Nulla facilisi. Praesent volutpat feugiat ante, a posuere tortor congue id. Nam posuere rhoncus purus dignissim facilisis.

Curabitur porttitor, orci vulputate rutrum vehicula, leo felis ultrices felis, sit amet commodo odio risus eget magna. Cras tempor neque bibendum metus luctus sollicitudin. Vestibulum vel leo sem. Fusce sit amet porta ligula, vel consequat dolor. Aenean quis vehicula dui, at volutpat arcu. Praesent consequat ac lorem ullamcorper mollis. Proin nec laoreet lacus. Etiam mollis pretium nulla, a facilisis metus placerat id. Ut venenatis odio in urna consequat fringilla eu id justo. Aliquam gravida libero in sapien tincidunt, a iaculis neque laoreet.

Aliquam sit amet mi id leo commodo fringilla in id dui. Etiam leo lorem, tempus sed diam non, congue auctor nisl. Phasellus sagittis elit et orci auctor porttitor. Fusce nulla lorem, ornare quis rhoncus quis, efficitur pharetra massa. Suspendisse iaculis sed urna at posuere. Maecenas tempor posuere lectus, quis congue mi mattis et. Pellentesque a vehicula mauris. Maecenas metus urna, dapibus et augue a, semper vestibulum orci. Etiam consequat ante eget ultricies elementum. Pellentesque vehicula et dolor eget commodo. Nunc tincidunt augue sapien, vitae lobortis quam molestie vitae. Integer porttitor leo quis urna sodales maximus sit amet vel ligula. Nunc magna elit, finibus a semper lacinia, fringilla egestas lectus. Quisque molestie rutrum dapibus. Donec tincidunt viverra posuere.

Duis ut gravida felis. Curabitur id purus justo. Nulla aliquam lacinia diam, ac pretium justo semper vitae. Ut porttitor nulla non sem maximus finibus. Aliquam dignissim dui neque, id sagittis dolor interdum ac. Nullam id laoreet massa, a blandit metus. Curabitur vitae eros malesuada, vestibulum quam tincidunt, pellentesque ligula. Nullam eros neque, bibendum id porttitor at, pretium id ipsum. Aliquam eget erat lacinia, porttitor mauris nec, accumsan urna.

Vestibulum ornare tortor quis malesuada porttitor. Morbi posuere pretium aliquam. Praesent sed lectus sed diam pellentesque dignissim. Orci varius natoque penatibus et magnis dis parturient montes, nascetur ridiculus mus. Pellentesque nunc libero, sodales non gravida porta, aliquet at massa. Sed diam massa, vehicula eget accumsan sed, consequat sed libero. Mauris at elit malesuada, elementum nisl sed, fringilla tellus. Donec tincidunt convallis ligula eu luctus.

Duis pulvinar felis sit amet est fringilla condimentum. Nam varius elit quis neque tincidunt efficitur a sed sapien. Integer vel condimentum dui. Aenean ac tincidunt augue. Phasellus nec viverra est. Phasellus faucibus velit et congue sodales. Sed non mollis ipsum. Fusce sed tincidunt purus. Fusce vitae odio diam. Sed at diam eu odio laoreet blandit nec id velit. Donec ultricies turpis augue.

Vestibulum ante ipsum primis in faucibus orci luctus et ultrices posuere cubilia Curae; Maecenas varius pharetra lacus eget accumsan. Aliquam malesuada lorem hendrerit felis vestibulum, non aliquet eros gravida. Aliquam erat volutpat. Curabitur cursus ultrices ante, id pharetra mi tristique ut. Interdum et malesuada fames ac ante ipsum primis in faucibus. Aenean ornare, nunc quis venenatis mattis, velit erat elementum est, eget ultrices felis ante quis orci. Nam finibus dui vitae ipsum rhoncus ornare. Proin congue dignissim dictum. Suspendisse potenti. Curabitur sit amet metus mattis neque congue finibus vel in ligula. Nam sit amet erat pretium, facilisis lacus sed, dapibus nulla. Sed vehicula tincidunt aliquet. Quisque scelerisque mattis mauris, non placerat massa venenatis vitae.

Sed non justo a odio faucibus dignissim a ut est. Cras vel lectus felis. Nullam sed luctus sem. Fusce risus lacus, condimentum vitae sagittis eu, finibus ultricies metus. Morbi sollicitudin, erat vel gravida feugiat, ipsum odio tempus justo, eget finibus ante nisl et neque. Phasellus a nunc eu nunc ultrices interdum. Aenean tincidunt viverra mauris, et bibendum sapien placerat ut. Nam sed leo at sapien mattis aliquam eget in mi.

Pellentesque aliquam sit amet ante commodo viverra. Cras tellus justo, suscipit in pharetra non, molestie suscipit massa. Donec ornare nisi eget ligula fermentum congue. Aliquam ultrices sit amet dolor non molestie. Integer tempor lacinia pharetra. Praesent accumsan lacinia ligula, ac laoreet neque varius eget. Aenean posuere metus urna, auctor ultrices tellus bibendum sit amet. Aenean accumsan dapibus mauris a pretium. Nam venenatis metus a velit mollis, et porta tellus varius. Nunc tortor mi, pulvinar posuere ornare id, vehicula nec arcu. Etiam tincidunt in dolor at congue. In et turpis orci. Aenean egestas sem et tellus placerat, in interdum sapien pretium. Duis sodales orci et urna gravida efficitur. Cras accumsan urna convallis orci blandit, ut porttitor turpis viverra. Morbi dapibus nunc et turpis mattis interdum.

Sed accumsan sodales nunc, sit amet aliquam urna varius non. Donec ac quam est. Proin convallis augue at erat ultricies, quis convallis lorem cursus. Phasellus ullamcorper sodales posuere. Sed interdum lectus vel ipsum scelerisque, non convallis eros finibus. Fusce congue sapien sed ante auctor, vel lacinia enim egestas. Aenean quis elit et libero consequat convallis sollicitudin ut elit.

Fusce bibendum blandit dui vitae pulvinar. Aenean blandit aliquet fringilla. Sed commodo orci sed scelerisque consectetur. Ut nec dui faucibus, sollicitudin ipsum tincidunt, molestie dolor. Mauris a aliquam mi. Vivamus tempor turpis vitae diam malesuada ultricies. Suspendisse tincidunt sodales risus, hendrerit gravida est. Sed sit amet orci sed massa dignissim facilisis.

Phasellus ante erat, lacinia a eleifend et, blandit vel nisi. Sed eu arcu eget elit pellentesque tristique in nec ipsum. Nunc in elit ligula. Morbi aliquet, arcu vel consequat ultricies, dolor elit molestie odio, quis dictum nibh leo id nisl. Etiam sit amet lacus at velit vehicula rhoncus ut eu leo. Maecenas dictum condimentum eros, et fermentum sem elementum vel. Nam elit sapien, tristique at viverra et, dictum non dui. Donec velit est, consequat in quam in, scelerisque tincidunt massa. Class aptent taciti sociosqu ad litora torquent per conubia nostra, per inceptos himenaeos. Mauris a viverra est, id consectetur est. Nam sed sollicitudin lectus.

Quisque blandit justo neque, vitae blandit erat pharetra id. Quisque sit amet nulla a neque volutpat ornare. Quisque faucibus lobortis dui, eget dignissim urna pharetra quis. Integer vel erat sit amet enim dictum cursus. Pellentesque ut mi tristique, tristique justo quis, faucibus libero. Cras finibus auctor faucibus. Duis eget fermentum sapien, sed vestibulum nisl. Nunc dignissim pellentesque tellus, eget ultrices dui laoreet euismod.

In dictum ipsum est, eget hendrerit purus rhoncus a. Nullam fermentum, velit eget feugiat tincidunt, eros nisi sodales tellus, vel convallis erat urna a ipsum. Vestibulum vulputate consectetur urna, sit amet volutpat ipsum. Nunc venenatis nisi in ante mattis, id condimentum risus dapibus. In lorem tortor, gravida sed luctus id, venenatis eu metus. Praesent sed purus est. In cursus tortor nec tellus pulvinar tristique. Aliquam sit amet dui sit amet tellus sollicitudin malesuada. Etiam auctor eros venenatis neque porttitor malesuada. In sed enim fringilla, pharetra nisi eget, malesuada purus. Aenean ullamcorper maximus dolor ac ullamcorper. Nulla nisi erat, cursus at erat nec, venenatis feugiat orci. Morbi quis turpis sed tellus porttitor maximus et sit amet metus.

Donec volutpat a sem vel luctus. Proin luctus aliquet tortor quis luctus. Duis sagittis lacinia placerat. Integer eu venenatis quam. In tristique diam vel vehicula pellentesque. Proin faucibus rhoncus ultrices. Nam porttitor orci magna, non pulvinar diam interdum id. Duis nulla enim, auctor sed feugiat at, vehicula nec tortor.

Cras tempus aliquam nunc in feugiat. Vivamus mattis finibus nisi sed commodo. Ut vitae viverra nunc, id accumsan diam. Nulla id nisi euismod, commodo justo quis, volutpat ex. Nullam posuere at velit at blandit. Aliquam nisi sapien, lacinia eu enim ac, laoreet tempus diam. Integer lobortis arcu dui, non auctor arcu auctor ac. Vestibulum semper lorem tellus, a venenatis erat mattis vel. Fusce scelerisque ex at nunc ullamcorper, et tristique leo vulputate.

Morbi tincidunt consectetur orci aliquam suscipit. Phasellus sit amet enim vestibulum, tincidunt eros ac, ornare arcu. Integer ut augue in sem blandit consectetur vel eu leo. Sed est eros, pretium eget nisl sed, dictum porta nunc. Etiam ut tincidunt urna. Curabitur nec nisl scelerisque, rutrum mi eget, tincidunt risus. Morbi tempus elit sit amet purus dictum egestas.

Maecenas id ipsum sit amet leo tristique placerat. Nunc efficitur elementum mauris in vehicula. Aenean quis mi a elit varius blandit tincidunt quis massa. Proin convallis neque turpis. Aliquam erat volutpat. Phasellus dolor eros, ultricies vel vestibulum ac, ornare efficitur enim. Aenean at metus ac elit accumsan sodales. Vestibulum tempor commodo vehicula. Praesent id laoreet quam, vitae eleifend ligula.

Quisque semper magna orci, non semper leo malesuada sed. Nullam pellentesque urna sit amet arcu tempor cursus. Morbi eleifend tempus ante quis ornare. Quisque laoreet nunc massa, sit amet laoreet lectus venenatis ut. Donec eget nisl id quam fringilla pulvinar. Nullam ut tincidunt magna. Maecenas tristique congue sem et mollis. Cras consectetur bibendum purus eget tincidunt. Pellentesque semper nisl vitae leo venenatis, sit amet viverra mi pharetra. Phasellus eu nisl est. Praesent vel tortor at mauris finibus posuere. Nulla facilisi. Sed nibh urna, ultricies id ex sit amet, vehicula vulputate velit. Sed dignissim lorem in enim imperdiet suscipit.

Etiam laoreet orci id lorem ullamcorper posuere. Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. In erat mi, auctor nec viverra id, vulputate nec ante. In rhoncus arcu magna, in commodo erat porttitor sit amet. Duis ultrices elementum pharetra. Vivamus tincidunt, lacus sed varius tempus, diam enim pharetra urna, eget auctor massa justo eu neque. Vestibulum vel placerat libero, at aliquet dolor. Duis augue ipsum, convallis at arcu eget, porttitor consectetur elit. Fusce quam quam, condimentum ut imperdiet in, faucibus quis urna. Aliquam dui neque, gravida nec mauris eu, accumsan mattis orci. Etiam quam elit, accumsan ac ex nec, porta pellentesque ipsum. Morbi posuere eleifend justo. Pellentesque eu finibus lectus. Pellentesque ex ipsum, vulputate id felis eu, varius aliquet purus. Integer vel augue at risus interdum placerat. Phasellus ac tortor nibh.