
ACT leader David Seymour yesterday unveiled what he must believe is a cunning plan to undermine New Zealand’s climate change policies.
Though there had been speculation that when he announced ACT’s climate change policy for the next election, he would call for New Zealand to withdraw from the Paris Agreement on Climate Change, he did not quite do that.
Instead, he left the threat hanging in the background if the Government fails to change the methane reduction targets.
But the fine print of the policy shows that what he wants is exactly what the Ministerial targets review committee recommended last December.
That would see methane emissions reduced by between 14 and 24 per cent from their 2017 level.
As Associate Agriculture Minister and ACT MP Andrew Hoggard pointed out, farmers are on track to a 10 per cent reduction by 2030, so they would have another 20 years after that to achieve the final four per cent reduction.
And to pitch the policy to urban voters, he is calling for the removal of ETS levies from coal used to fire the Huntly Power Station boilers.
Doing that, he said, would reduce peak electricity prices.

But what was important about yesterday’s announcement on a Patumahoe farm was not so much what he said but what people might have thought he said.
That much was evident in the response from Groundswell founder, Bryce McKenzie, on “The Country” yesterday.
“I think it’s great for New Zealand farmers and for New Zealand generally to be quite honest,” said McKenzie.
“We’re pleasantly surprised by his forthrightness.
“We didn’t expect this to come. We knew there was an announcement coming. Didn’t expect them to go as far as they have. Maybe a good compromise in the finish.”
ACT had talked to Groundswell about the policy.
Seymour told POLITIK the relationship between Groundswell and ACT was “very warm”.
“ If you’re talking about the ACT party, there’s not a connection between the board of the party or an official policy or anything like that,” he said.
“But certainly Mark (Cameron) and Andrew (Hoggard) get out, they listen to people, they take meetings if people ask to meet with them, as I’d expect all my MPs to do with anyone in the country.”
Seymour said he personally had the final sign-off on any ACT policy.
“I don’t really have any connection with them.
“ I have no doubt that they have had an influence on the formation of the policy, as will the Feds (Federated Farmers), as well as Beef and Lamb.
“I sat down with the Chief Executive of Fonterra a month ago.”
But whereas Groundswell’s ideas on climate change made it through to the policy, ACT did not pick up on what Fonterra had to say.
Seymour said Fonterra CEO Miles Hurrell told him he needed to source milk produced in a special way to please customers in Europe.
That was a reference to Fonterra’s biggest customer, Nestle, which has a declared intention that all of its procured dairy ingredients will come from net-zero farms by 2050.
But this has obviously not impressed Seymour.
“It’s not true that because one person has a strategy in the market, all of us should be compelled to do it, often at cost to their livelihoods,” he said.
“So, I actually think we need to be really clear; Paris is back on the table. The Paris agreement is like a bad boyfriend. Either it’s got to change, stop the abuse, or we’re going to leave.“
ACT, by relying on Groundswell, may be misreading farmer opinion.
Dairy NZ have confirmed that its chair and a sitting director have just been re-elected unopposed to the organisation’s board.
Both the chair, Tracey Brown and board member Chris Lewis represent the kind of views put forward by Fonterra rather than Groundswell.

However, ACT’s move has left New Zealand First in an awkward situation that is amplified by their annual conference coming up this weekend.
There are some who believe ACT’s decision to make its announcement yesterday was made with the New Zealand First conference in mind.
Seymour yesterday was at pains to point out that New Zealand First had voted for the Net Zero legislation back in 2019.
In fact, New Zealand First, then in coalition with Labour, blocked amendments that National tried to make to the legislation to have the Climate Change Commission review the same methane targets that ACT now wants reduced.
“They (NZ First) can’t say, over the last two years, that they stand on the side of regional and rural New Zealand,” said National’s leader, Simon Bridges, in the debate in the House.
“They blocked our amendments last night to this Bill out of ignorance and petty partisan politics.”
Despite this, National supported the legislation, and Bridge promised the targets would be reviewed in the first 100 days of a National government.
The Luxon Government did commission a review which reported last December and proposed that methane emissions be reduced by between 14-15 per cent and 24 per cent to produce no increased warming from 2017.
ACT has taken the bottom of that range as its preferred target, and it is likely that New Zealand First will land in much the same place.
ACT’s proposal to lower power prices by removing the ETS Levy (an earlier version mnisnamed this as GST) from thermal coal used to fire the Huntly Power Station could have the potential, based on the current ETS price and international coal prices, to nearly halve the price of coal to Genesis.
But that assumes that coal is the only item forcing higher power prices. A year ago, when hydro lakes were nearly empty, thermal generation made up only about 20 – 25 per cent of the overall generation mix.
Seymour said he believed it was critical that political parties put their cards on the table before the next election and say what their position was on the Paris Climate Change Agreement before the next election.
ACT was simple, he said. Either the targets changed, or ACT would advocate that New Zealand pull out.
Would that then be a bottom line?
“What I’ve found is that it can be very effective without saying it’s a bottom line,” he said.
“If you look at what we’ve managed to achieve as a party that has one sixth of the Government, I think you can see that we’ve got a pretty good form and we’ve got good form on this issue.
“I voted one against 119 against the Zero Carbon Act, and I said it was bad then; I know it’s bad now.
“I think what’s happening today is that we say, look, this issue is back on the table. Paris is back at the table; the world should take note that we are not going to sit idly by and watch New Zealand destroyed for a fantasy that actually no one else believes.”
The last thing the Government would want is to have to pull out of the Paris Climate Change Accord.
The only UN members not part of it are Iran, Libya, Yemen and the United States.
But given Simon Bridges’ undertaking in 2019, the chances of it reviewing the 2050 methane targets are high.



