Donald Trump may have shattered National’s whole re-election scenario.
The admission yesterday by the Finance Minister that the Middle East war could knock half a per cent off growth figures shrinks the chances of an economic recovery.
National has been counting on that to bring them over the line in November.
Back on January 19, in his State of the Nation speech, Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said the “back on track: economic recovery had arrived.
“I feel more confident than ever that the recovery has now arrived and Kiwis can look forward to a year which is brighter than the last few,” he said.
But yesterday, Finance Minister Nicola Willis tempered that optimism with Treasury reports on what oil-price-induced inflation would do to the New Zealand economy.
“The latest treasury forecasts I’ve received say that actually across a range of scenarios, they would still expect our economy to keep growing this year, just not as fast as might otherwise have been the case,” she said on TVNZ’s “Q+A”.
“Treasury are advising me that GDP could be anything between 0.1, 0.3 and 0.5 per cent lower than would otherwise have been the case.
“That’s against a backdrop of them forecasting 3% for the year.
“They haven’t given me a scenario in which they say GDP would go backwards.
“They’ve given me scenarios in which, they say, depending on secondary effects, you could see GDP go incrementally lower than we’re forecasting currently.”
And with that drop in growth could come a revision upwards of unemployment figures.
“If we see downgrades to growth, that has downgrades to job creation as well,” she said.
Westpac Chief Economist Kelly Eckhold ism more pessimistic than Willis and has forecast a drop in growth of between 0.5 and 1.0 per cent if the Traits of Hormuz are closed for longer than three months

Willis is giving all the signs that the Government is already in crisis-management mode.
She said she had met on Saturday morning with Reserve Bank Governor Anna Breman and Treasury Secretary Iain Rennie to discuss the crisis.
Her tone on “Q+A” gives an indication that the meeting was a sober one, obviously discussing worst-case scenarios.
The immediate worry is inflation.
“In a scenario where we are seeing sustained increases in fuel prices, you would expect that inflation would be higher than would otherwise be the case,” Willis said yesterday.
“ It may be that it still hovers at or above that 3% rate down the line, but then you also have to consider the secondary effects because the first hit is to what happens with petrol prices, but the second hit is how that adds to freight prices, the price of food, other things across the economy.
“So you would expect some lingering effects to inflation. And all things being equal, that happening also has a downward impact on growth.”
Across the Tasman, Australian Treasurer Jim Chalmers has been more specific about the impact of the crisis on inflation in Australia, and he is forecasting a much higher rate than Willis.
He has revealed inflation could climb into the “mid to high fours” because of the Middle East conflict.
Chalmers told Sky News Sunday Agenda that Treasury had been running scenarios examining the impact of higher oil prices on the economy ahead of the federal budget.
“It depends a bit, not just on the severity of this price shock coming out of the Middle East, but also its duration,” he said.
“We run a number of scenarios as well, just like the private banks do. We’ve got a couple of months to finalise the Treasury forecast for the Budget in May.
“So obviously we are working through scenarios and contingencies like this pretty much every day as we try and land these forecasts for the budget.”
Mr Chalmers said early modelling showed inflation could approach the five per cent mark if oil prices remain elevated.
“If we were putting pencils down on those forecasts today, we’d have inflation peaking somewhere between the mid to high fours,” he said.
“But there’s a little way to run yet. And the biggest variable … is really how long this drags out for.”
Meanwhile, there have been cases of people panic-buying petrol over the weekend.
That is despite assurances from the Government that we have enough for the immediate future.
But we are currently at Level Two of the National Fuel Plan, which allows the Government a wide range of reactions to the crisis.
It defines “moderate” to mean moderate fuel distribution impacts, with most customers still serviced, but causing risk of shortages to critical fuel customers.
The Fuel Sector Coordinating Committee, which consists of the oil importers and major retailers, is activated to monitor demand levels and resupply options and coordinate Government support as required for the fuel sector.
“Critical Fuel Customer prioritisation is invoked, and fuel companies are to take steps to ensure critical customers are supplied. Government powers may be used to enforce this,” the plan says.
That has not happened yet, but it is obviously a possibility.
As is the ultimate tool available under a moderate scenario, the declaration of a State of Emergency.
The plan describes critical customers as:
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
- Agriculture (including food supply chain, milk collections, preventing animal welfare issues, crops, fisheries, and activities of significant economic export value
- Airlines
- Civil defence emergency management (national/regional/local CDEM Group)
- Corrections (facilities and the monitoring of offenders in the community)
- Fire and Emergency New Zealand (FENZ) (response to public and property health and safety)
- Health and disability sector (hospitals, public health services, health emergency coordination centres, primary care, ambulance services, and aged care facilities)
- Lifeline utilities (major supplies of energy, transportation, telecommunications, water, and wastewater services)
- Lifeline utilities (major supplies of energy, transportation, telecommunications, water, and wastewater services)
- Local authorities, for lifeline utility services, solid waste and other essential functions
- New Zealand Police (response to public and property health and safety)
- New Zealand Search and Rescue
- NZ Defence Force (noting that they hold limited stocks for normal NZDF operations)
- Public transport – rail, bus and ferry
- Transport and storage of food, and
- Welfare services (household goods and services, Civil Defence Centres, Oranga Tamariki facilities, large-scale animal husbandry and veterinary officials).
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
The fact that this plan is now operational is an indication that this situation could yet develop into a Covid-type response from the Government.
Limiting people’s access to fuel carries a huge political risk for the Government, no matter how obvious the reason for that limitation might be.
There are immediate worries.
POLITIK understands that there are concerns about the level of aviation fuel that might be available and that there are also concerns about future supplies of fertiliser, particularly given the reduction in Taranaki gas output and the impact that could have on the Ballance Kapuni urea plant.
The political question now is when the Government decides that it is facing a major Covid-style crisis and that it will need to set up a communication channel with the country.
Even if that is not necessary, the likely economic damage so far will be enough to seriously worry the National Party Ministers in the Beehive.
Donald Trump may have derailed the plan to get New Zealand back on track.









